While EU legislators near a decision on the law on “chat control”, confidentiality experts provide that it could break the public’s confidence in digital communication and push users to web 3 platforms.
While European legislators near a decision on controversial “cat control” legislation, confidentiality experts warn that it could break the public’s confidence in digital communication and push users to web3 platforms.
At the center of the debate is the regulations proposed by the EU to prevent and fight sexual abuse on children, which would require platforms to scan private messages for illegal content before being encrypted. Critics say that this effectively creates a stolen door in encrypted systems, contradicting the EU’s own commitments to privacy.
“Giving an intrinsically corruptible entity almost unlimited in the privacy of individuals is incompatible with an honest digital value declaration,” said Diode to Cointelegraph Hans, co-founder and CEO. He described the proposal to overcome dangerous.
Elisenda Fabrega, lawyer general of Brickken, noted that the law seems “difficult to justify under the current jurisprudence of the Court of Justice of the European Union”. She highlighted articles 7 and 8 of the EU fundamental rights charter, which guarantees the confidentiality of communications and the protection of personal data.
“Customer side digitization would allow content monitoring on user devices before transmission, including in cases where there is no indication of illegal activity,” she said.
In relation: Us Treasury’s Defi ID plan is “ like putting cameras in all salons ”
EU law establishes a dangerous precedent
Experts say that the regulations establish a dangerous precedent from a legal and technological point of view. “There is no guarantee,” added repel, when asked if the tools could be used badly. “More than 10% of all data violations occur in government systems,” he warned.
Fabrega has raised concerns about the broader impact that such monitoring would have on the confidence of the public. “Encryption is not only a technical functionality, but it is a promise to users that their private communications will remain confidential,” she said.
Erosion of confidence in traditional messaging platforms could encourage users to explore decentralized web3 alternatives, platforms designed to protect data from user by design by design.
“The wrestling of Web3 privacy is” not your keys, not your data “,” said Augel. “It is a real self-leather for data,” he added, noting that the end user maintains sovereignty over their information from the “cradle at the grave”.
Fabrega has echoed the feeling, declaring that “users concerned with confidentiality will explore more and more decentralized web3 alternatives” if cat control has passed. She warned that change could “fragment the European digital market” and weaken EU’s ability to shape international standards on privacy.
In relation: The EU proposal to scan all private messages grows
The ball is in the German courtyard
Germany, which holds the central vote, has not yet taken a final position. While 15 EU countries currently support the proposal, they are not below the 65% population threshold required for the passage. If Germany votes in favor, the law will probably adopt; If it abstains or opposes, legislation should fail.
“We believe that it is weak,” said Augen about the probability of passage. “But it will not be the last time that there is an attempt to overthrow fundamental human rights in the name of security.”
Review: Astrology could make you a better crypto trader: it was predicted